Kush MotwaniAIR 11 · CSE 2023 · 443 wordsTheir whole copy
Opening · a quotation
"I have failed over and over in my life, and that is why I am successful."
Body · points and prose
- [Michael] Jordan (basketball), also called "Magic" Jordan.
The given statement deals with the importance of [perseverance] and [hard work] to achieve success in the face of adversity:
- [Success] = talent + right environment + hard work + perseverance
- "It took me 20 years to achieve overnight success"
- Results take time, so often must continue to work hard.
- Must learn from failures on the way.
- Hence life is called ["anubhav dhara"] - i.e., series of experiences.
In this context:
Adversity quotient is defined as ability to persevere in the face of hardship.
It [complements] other quotients necessary for success in public services.
Eg: IAS officer Durga Shakti Nagpal, who triumphed against mafia, despite threats.
Thus, AQ should be developed as part of Mission karmayogi.
(a) There are no ethical dilemma that I face in this situation:
Corruption is a "crime against humanity" according to UN.
[Justice] is the core ideal of the Constitution according to [Supreme Court] in [Haryana State Electricity Board case], and [BR Ambedkar]. In this case, the [families of the 2 children who have died], and the 30 children who are ill deserve [JUSTICE].
The variety of [ethical ISSUES] are: → falsely implicating bhojan-mata → supplying poor quality food → conflict of interest → head of the commission asking me to commit a wrongdoing → caste-discrimination, etc
Option 1: Do as head says
- Will lead to injustice
- Against H D Ross prima facie principles of honesty, beneficence, etc
- Against deontological ethics - as it is my duty as member of commission to ensure fair investigated.
Hence, bad option.
Option 2: Resign
- Against York Hillborn's principles of public morality → of conflict of interest
- Would not help the bhojan-mata/victims of the incident.
Hence, bad option.
Option 3: Convince the head of commission about the issue.
- Tell him this is an issue affecting [conscience of entire society].
- If it is found out [later] that commission did wrong doing → they would all be in trouble.
- If it is found out [later] that Minister's brother was informed → He would be criticized more.
- In fact: this is an opportunity for the minister to improve his standing → by taking action against his brother.
- This would restore trust of the public and of the district administration.
Close · a way forward
This is in line with various principles of ethics such as deontology, teleology, etc. Hence, I would choose this.
Children are the future of the country. All steps to empower them must be taken.