Ganesh Kumar BaskarAIR 7 · CSE 2019 · 265 wordsTheir whole copy
Opening
The case describes the classic dilemma between development and environmental protection. This case brings out the necessity for sustainable development to satisfy both the requirements.
Body · points and prose
(a)
Interests of Stakeholders
(I) NRI tycoon
- Conduct the marriage ceremony
- Environmental damages paid to ensure no interference by administration
- Ensure no obstacle to the function
(II) Local People + MLA
- Economic development
- Tourism to provide wealth and employment
- No large scale impact of environment
(III) M & DM
- Development as per wishes of people
- Environmental protection as per Environment (Protection) Act, 1986
(IV) Environment
- Be in of its pristine glory
(b) Options that are available
- Stop the marriage ceremony on the basis of feasibility report
- Allow marriage ceremony as the local community wishes as per citizen-centric governance.
- File petition with National Green Tribunal to decide
- Request for decision from higher authorities
- Make arrangements for protecting critical environment features while allowing the function
Course of action
I will choose option 5
- Request a detailed study to split environmental damages into Reversible and Irreversible
- Request the NRI tycoon to give details of ceremony
- Ban those activities that cause irreversible damage to environment
- Calculate the Net Present Value of the reversible damages along with an extra 10% for compensatory afforestation as environmental damages
- Allow NRI tycoon marriage with those activities that do not cause irreversible damage.
- Use the environmental damages for reversing the impact and improve the ecosystem further.
- Request the NRI to have a green marriage to advertise eco-friendly eco-friendliness.
Close · no separate close
None written.