Sociology I · 15 marks

Critically discuss the reservation policy as an instrument of social change in India.

Answered by 4 toppers · CSE 2016–2017

Syllabus: Stratification and Mobility: (a) Concepts- equality, inequality, hierarchy, exclusion, poverty and deprivation. (b) Theories of social stratification- Structural functionalist theory, Marxist theory, Weberian theory. (c) Dimensions – Social stratification of class, status groups, gender, ethnicity and race. (d) Social mobility- open and closed systems, types of mobility, sources and causes of mobility.

How toppers approached it

From 3 of the 4 answers · about 300 words.

Opening

  • No separate opening3 of 3

Body

  • Continuous prose2 of 3
  • Points1 of 3

Close

  • A summary2 of 3
  • No separate close1 of 3

The toppers’ answers

Sudhir KumarAIR 42 · CSE 2017 · 303 wordsTheir whole copy

Opening

India's Constitution provides for equitable, just, non-discriminating social order. Reservation policy is an outcome of it; providing positive discrimination to socially and educationally backward classes. The main motive is to provide equality of opportunity as backward classes lack institutional connections, structure, access to education - which are needed to advance.

Body · continuous prose

Reservation policy to SCs, STs, OBCs has led to their social mobility, signified by increasing share of these castes, classes in share of jobs, higher education etc. Reservation in state legislatures, Parliament, local self-government for SCs, STs has further deepened inter connections between different castes through tool of democracy.

India is a peculiar case with intermixing of caste and class social systems. Reservation is meant for social, educational advancement as higher castes cornered all jobs, education during historic, colonial times. However, there are cases of misuse and sectional benefits as SC, ST is not a single class. However, overall reservation policy has done great work in upholding constitutional values.

In recent times, there is an agitation seen against reservation policy. It is an outcome of failed economic policies, shrinking land and a hurt of ego as higher castes cant digest the upward mobility of so called 'lower castes and classes'.

Close · a summary

M.N Srinivas gave concepts of Sanskritisation as a means of social mobility in ascripted caste structure. Reservation is part of Westernization. However, despite intended benefits of reservation as social change agent - more acceptability for lower castes, equal opportunities, equal citizenship; these have not been fully realized. Because in villages, lower caste sarpanch still sit on floor in front of high caste members, meagre representation in higher education, atrocities against caste, dalits; the continuing practice of caste-based manual scavenging etc. Thus reservation is not a panacea for all round social change but is an important cog in wheel of upliftment of lower caste.

More on Equality, Inequality and Exclusion

The concepts of equality, inequality, hierarchy, exclusion, poverty and deprivation.

All Sociology I questions on Equality, Inequality and Exclusion