GS4 · 10 marks · 150 words

Socially and economically marginalized women are used to make a profit, often at the cost of their own health and reproductive autonomy, in the name of commercial surrogacy. Discuss the ethical issues associated with commercial surrogacy in India. Should commercial surrogacy be completely banned?

Answered by 3 toppers · CSE 2016–2018

Syllabus: Ethics and Human Interface: Essence, determinants and consequences of Ethics in-human actions; dimensions of ethics; ethics - in private and public relationships. Human Values - lessons from the lives and teachings of great leaders, reformers and administrators; role of family society and educational institutions in inculcating values.

How toppers approached it

From all 3 answers · about 240 words.

Opening

  • A definition2 of 3
  • No separate opening1 of 3

Body

  • Points and prose2 of 3
  • Points1 of 3

Close

  • A way forward3 of 3

The toppers’ answers

Namrata JainAIR 12 · CSE 2018 · 163 wordsTheir whole copy

Opening

The surrogacy often comes to rescue by offering money to socially and economically marginalised section because of poor regulatory process resulting in their exploitation. The ethical issues associated with commercial surrogacy are:

Body · points and prose

(1) Right of women over her body v/s the state's decision: It is the women's right over the body and her decision on how to earn. But this comes with the exploitative role.

(2) The job opportunities lacking v/s state's regulation. (3) Social & economical impact on women v/s the benefits of women earning. (4) Traditional values over the modern values.

Close · a way forward

The banning of commercial surrogacy has both its adv & disadv:

AdvDisadv
1. Ensure no exploitation1. no mechanism to provide the job.
2. No women's exploitation as well as earning altruistic surrogacy takes place

Thus, it is good to stop the exploitation but with the measures to ensure no marginalisation and providing adequate jobs.

More on Dimensions of Ethics

What ethics is and how it is divided: descriptive, normative and applied ethics, the essence and determinants of ethical action, consequences of ethics in human action.

All GS4 questions on Dimensions of Ethics