BensonAIR 90 · CSE 2017 · 360 wordsTheir whole copy
Opening
Durkheim studied societies and was seeking to explain how order is maintained in society.
Body · points and prose
He studied preliterate societies as being low on technology, simple division of labour, strong collective conscience, similarity of occupation and so mechanically linked. The violations were severely condemned by repressive laws. The similarity was hence cause of solidarity, as each produced and worked for group.
Similarly in modern industrial society, it was based on high technology, complex division of labour as society was further
differentiated, specialisation of occupation and hence organically linked. The differences and specialisation made each person dependent on other to fulfill their needs. As a result a new solidarity developed due to value consensus and interdependence, which held society together.
The collective conscience was not so strong as religion was overtaken by education in promoting generalized values. Hence deviation was met with restitutive law, as collective conscience was not hurt.
Durkheim however fails to account for how values are generated. It could be ruling class ideology.
Also industrial society has seen many conflicts between workers, owners etc showing the value consensus does not exist.
Moreover social change has been projected as orderly but we see from French Revolution it wasn't.
Contemporary trend in labour (Post Industrial Society- Daniel Bell) show growth of services in India and neglect of agriculture. As a result there is rural, urban labourer conflict and stress (farmer suicides).
Moreover lack of skill has made workers unemployable creating poverty and social strife.
There is no value consensus on labour issues as seen in recent Brexit and Sons of Soil Movement in Assam, Maharashtra, negating organic solidarity.
Gender as a dimension has also been ignored in Durkheim's theory. This becomes more relevant as democracies ensure women's equal rights.
Women are entering the workforce in large numbers and many view it as threat to family and male jobs (Margaret Benson).
Apart from class divide, race and caste are categories that prevent solidarity. e.g. Black Lives Matter and Dalit massacre at Khairlanji.
Increasing differentiation has led to social conflict rather than disintegration as seen by OBC status demand by Jats, Marathas etc.
Close · a summary
However Durkheim's insight is valuable in understanding cohesion in industrial society.