GS1 · 15 marks · 250 words

Compare and contrast the features of ancient Indian universities like Nalanda and Takshashila with modern state-funded universities in India. What lessons can modern universities learn from ancient ones to improve their effectiveness?

Answered by 9 toppers · CSE 2022–2025

Syllabus: Indian Culture- Salient aspects of Art Forms, Literature and Architecture from ancient to modern times.

How toppers approached it

From 7 of the 9 answers · about 230 words · 71% drew a diagram.

Opening

  • No separate opening86%
  • A date or context14%

Body

  • Points and prose86%
  • Points14%

Close

  • A summary43%
  • No separate close29%
  • A way forward29%

The toppers’ answers

Raghav JhunjhunwalaAIR 4 · CSE 2025 · 307 wordsTheir whole copy

Opening

The recent opening of Nalanda 2.0 has stoked the needs to revisit our rich pasts & derive critical lessons for today's ailing universities.

Body · points and prose

Contrasting Features

BasisNalanda-taxilamodern univ.
(1) curriculumHighly Independent & cutting-edge learning, topmost discourseFixed, no Autonomy to colleges except the premiere ones (like IITs)
(2) Regulatorymore freedom & AutonomyRegulatory jungle today & over restrictions
(3) multidisciplinary EducationBuddhism, Indian School, etc.Focus upon stream specialization & watertight separation
(4) RelationshipsGuru-shishya paramparaTeachers as absent Ring masters, Profit motive

Comparable Features

BasisNalanda-taxilamodern univ.
(1) Global connectmahayanists from round the world came to study @taxila, nalandaNEP 2020 encourages Cross-border branch opening
(2) merit basisNalanda had its own Entrance Exam, very stricttoday's: paper leaks controversy etc
(3) Dedicated learning centreslarge campus sizes, with dedicated facilities like hostels, etc.

Ancient produced : Buddha, Kautilya

Today's Production : Satya Nadella

What lessons need to be drawn today?

(1) Autonomy a) ↳ Institutions must be allowed to frame own curriculum & design courses.

(2) Expenditure a) ↳ we are much behind the levels recommended by TSR Subramanian committee (6%) b) ↳ need to invest more in R&D, Infra Boost

(3) Objective & Aims a) ↳ older Institutions focussed more upon value-based & skill based Education

(4) Pedagogy

Close

Discourse & Debate based --> marks & Exam based

Today only ~50.3% Graduates Employable (India Skills Report, 2023)

It's now high time, the cultural pasts & its grandeur is revived by India once again: 'VidyaDhanam Sarvapradhanam'

More on Ancient India

Indus Valley to early medieval: polity, society, religion and material culture before c. 800 CE.

All GS1 questions on Ancient India