Question 1(a) · 10 marks · 146 words written
Limitations of indological approach
Opening · a definition
Indology means the systematic study of Indian society on the basis of texts such as Ramayan, Upanishads (religious) and arthashastra (non-religious) etc. It was started by Ghurye, in response to the growing orientalist view of Indian society. Dumont is also a prominent indologist.
LIMITATIONS
Body · points
- It provides a book view which is devoid of field view (M.N. Srinivas)
- Not a secular approach
- Lacks objectivity and empiricity
- Equates Hindu society with Indian society
- Ignores medieval history of India and presence of other religions.
- Presents caste as an integrating force and ignores its dysfunctions.
- According to his critics, instead of aiding him (Ghurye) in understanding Indian society, book view disrupted his understanding.
Close · a summary
Inspite of the criticism, Indological approach laid the foundations of Indian sociology and aided in the development of other perspectives such as structural functionalism (M.N. Srinivas) in the later years.