Sociology II · 20 marks

A legalistic approach to increasing the age at marriage will produce positive results only if structural factors prevailing in the society are properly addressed. Discuss.

Answered by 3 toppers · CSE 2022–2023

Syllabus: Systems of Kinship in India: (a) Lineage and descent in India. (b) Types of kinship systems. (c) Family and marriage in India. (d) Household dimensions of the family. (e) Patriarchy, entitlements and sexual division of labour.

How toppers approached it

From 1 of the 3 answers · about 290 words · 100% drew a diagram.

Opening

  • A date or context1 of 1

Body

  • Points and prose1 of 1

Close

  • A summary1 of 1

The toppers’ answers

Pooja MalaniAIR 306 · CSE 2023 · 290 wordsTheir whole copy

Opening · a recent event

Jaya Jaitley Task force was set up to recommend over increasing minimum age of marriage for girls.

Body · points and prose

Need of increasing age

  • Discrepancy in minimum age of marriage of girls and boys defeat constitutional notion of equality (A-14)

  • Early-age of marriage perpetuate a vicious cycle along with high fertility rate.

Diagram
[Early age at marriage] --> [High fertility rate] --> [Unwanted girl child] [Early age at marriage] --> [Son meta preference] --> [Unwanted girl child] [Unwanted girl child] --> [Neglect of education] --> [Lack of job] --> [Early age at marriage]

Structural factors need to be addressed

Rational behind increasing age of marriage is to make women empowered. But empowerment depends on many factors as follows:-

(1) Women are confined to low paid informal jobs due to pink collarization and glass ceiling. [Karuna Ahmed]

This needs to be improved by skilling of women under PM Kaushal Yojana.

(2) Education of a girl child is neglected by parents due to onus of dowry. [Nivedita Menon]

This needs to be improved by strict implementation of Right to Education Act.

(3) Families still stress for male - breadwinner and glorify women's role as mother and wife - [Germaine Greer]

Need is to create symmetrical family [Young & Wilmott's] by raising awareness.

(4) Son-meta preference and patriarchal bargain are root causes of unwanted girl children and their exploitation. As explained by [Surinder S Jodhka]

This needs to be improved by strict penalties under PCPNDT Act, and behavioural change.

(5) Child marriages' prevalance at micro level (in villages) despite law at macro level (national level) cause hindrance to social change.

Close · a summary

This discrepancy between micro and macro was explained by [Yogendra Singh] in terms of resilience to change of a system.

Further, issues like domestic violence, marital rape need to be resolved in order to make institution of marriage more inclusive.

Hence, with cultural changes in accordance with progressive society, structural changes to yield positive results is also necessary as highlighted by [Ann Oakley].

More on Patriarchy and Entitlements

Patriarchy, women's entitlements and the sexual division of labour in India.

All Sociology II questions on Patriarchy and Entitlements