Sociology II · 15 marks

What evidence would you offer against the view that 'tribes are primitive communities living isolated lives untouched by civilization'?

Answered by 4 toppers · CSE 2016–2017

Syllabus: Tribal communities in India: (a) Definitional problems. (b) Geographical spread. (c) Colonial policies and tribes. (d) Issues of integration and autonomy.

How toppers approached it

From 3 of the 4 answers · about 220 words.

Opening

  • A definition1 of 3
  • No separate opening1 of 3
  • A restatement1 of 3

Body

  • Continuous prose2 of 3
  • Points1 of 3

Close

  • No separate close2 of 3
  • A summary1 of 3

The toppers’ answers

Sudhir KumarAIR 42 · CSE 2017 · 248 wordsTheir whole copy

Opening · a definition

Tribes are the aboriginals - original inhabitants. But the idea that tribes are someone living in jungles, totally untouched is based on wrong grounds.

Body · continuous prose

GS Ghurye says that tribes are not primitive communities but that they are misplaced tribes who could not be integrated well in the caste structure.

Moreover, tribes were not always the suppressed ones. Rather, they used to be kingdoms ruled by tribals.

They had a full flourished economies, having constant economic and labour exchange with outside world.

There is study to show that tribals work in farmlands in peak agricultural season and this is continuing from many centuries.

With advent of Britishers, the downturn started. It marginalized tribes by introducing outsiders and totally destroying their way of life. Moneylenders led them into debt trap and this led to confiscation

Close · a summary

of their land. Post-independence, India followed Panchsheel approach towards tribals along with positive discrimination. It bore some fruit. At present, there are very few tribes living untouched (example Jarawas). Reservation policy has led to their integration with rest of Indian society. It has led to assimilation of ideas of animism in caste society. It is found in a study that tribals worship Hindu Gods (local deity) and also celebrate their festivals. Tribes in North East have mainly adopted christianity, thus showing effect of religion. Also tribes are not un-divided, rather are socially differentiated on many accounts. Thus we can say that tribes are relatively isolated communities having less contact with others and maintaining their culture

More on Tribal Communities

Definitional problems, geographical spread, colonial policies, and integration and autonomy of tribes.

All Sociology II questions on Tribal Communities