Sociology I · 20 marks

“Weber’s approach to stratification was built on the analysis developed by Marx, but he modified and elaborated on it”. Discuss.

Answered by 5 toppers · CSE 2017–2021

Syllabus: Stratification and Mobility: (a) Concepts- equality, inequality, hierarchy, exclusion, poverty and deprivation. (b) Theories of social stratification- Structural functionalist theory, Marxist theory, Weberian theory. (c) Dimensions – Social stratification of class, status groups, gender, ethnicity and race. (d) Social mobility- open and closed systems, types of mobility, sources and causes of mobility.

How toppers approached it

From all 5 answers · about 310 words · 20% drew a diagram.

Opening

  • A definition60%
  • No separate opening40%

Body

  • Points and prose60%
  • Points40%

Close

  • A summary100%

The toppers’ answers

Priyamvada Ashok MhaddalkarAIR 13 · CSE 2021 · 217 wordsTheir whole copy

Opening · a definition

Social stratification means the division of different social groups into layers which may or may not be hierarchical.

Body · points

  • Karl Marx and Max Weber have immensely contributed to the understanding of social stratification through their theories.

Marx's view on stratification

  • Marx proposed a uniaxal stratification theory based on class.

  • According to Marx, the class of an individual depends on his relations with the means of production.

  • He divided society into two classes: haves and have nots.

  • In the capitalist society due to inherent contradictions, the haves (Bourgeoisie) make profit using the labour of the have nots (Proletariat).

  • As the system progresses, due to pauperization the Proletariat class will expand and society will be polarized.

Weber's Theory of Stratification

  • Max Weber while drawing from Marx's theory proposes a trinitarian model
  • Stratification occurs along 3 axes - class, status, power(party).
  • Thus he steps away from Marx's economic determinism and says that even status-prestige and

political power play a role in determining the position of an individual in society.

  • Weber argued that as the capitalist society progresses there will be increasing rationalization and this will lead to creation of middle class
Diagram
Bourgeoisie / \ / No middle \ / class \ ----------------- Proletariat Marx Bourgeoisie / \ / Middle class\ \ / \ Proletariat/ --------- Weber

Close · a summary

Thus, Weber modified Marx's stratification theory which was based only on class to make it a trinitarian model of stratification.

More on Theories of Stratification

Structural-functionalist (Davis and Moore), Marxist and Weberian theories of social stratification.

All Sociology I questions on Theories of Stratification