Sociology I · 20 marks

Race, gender and caste as a hierarchical system (perfected inequality) has become a thing of the past, now it has become more of a competitive system where inequality on the basis of merit (practical inequality) is ingrained in the system. Elucidate with the help of suitable examples.

Answered by 3 toppers · CSE 2022–2024

Syllabus: Stratification and Mobility: (a) Concepts- equality, inequality, hierarchy, exclusion, poverty and deprivation. (b) Theories of social stratification- Structural functionalist theory, Marxist theory, Weberian theory. (c) Dimensions – Social stratification of class, status groups, gender, ethnicity and race. (d) Social mobility- open and closed systems, types of mobility, sources and causes of mobility.

How toppers approached it

From 2 of the 3 answers · about 310 words · 50% drew a diagram.

Opening

  • A definition2 of 2

Body

  • Points and prose1 of 2
  • Points1 of 2

Close

  • A summary2 of 2

The toppers’ answers

Aayushi BansalAIR 7 · CSE 2024 · 311 wordsTheir whole copy

Opening · a definition

Hierarchical system refers to a closed society with no scope for social mobility.

Body · points

Race

It is a sociological category of stratification, where a society perceives a group as different & unequal based on biological & social characteristics.

In the past, Blacks were discriminated in terms of income, status, power & denied even basic human rights. (Eg Jim Crow Law for racial profiling & surveillance in USA). Eg → Apartheid in South Africa.

Today, race has emerged has competitive equality. US Constitution provides equal rights to blacks, racism is ablished in South Africa. Eg → US had the first Black President Barack Obama → increasing representation in education & public services.

Gender

Gender is a social construct. Heteronormative order of the past valued heterosexual males over females & LGBT community. Ann Oakley, calls this housewifization. Today, equal rights, legislations & education are giving equality of opportunity. Women's increasing labour force participation → rise of symmetrical family (Willmott & Young).

Recognition of LGBT (eg reading down of Section 377, decriminalising homosexuality in India) are few cases. Eg → merit based recruitment to public services, bureaucracy.

Caste

Caste is an endogamic & segmental category unique to India. Past was defined by socio-civic disabilities, untouchability & poverty for lower castes. With Constitutionalism, rising education, urbanisation & secularisation has helped backward castes climb up. In the realm of market & capitalism, ability & merit makes one successful.

eg → Dalit entrepreneurs Kalpana Saroj, Shiv Nadar

→ farmers (backward caste) competing for exports in globalised world.

Close · a summary

However, it would be unjustified to claim that merit is now completely ingrained in system. Racial profiling in US, Black lives matter movement, occupational segregation of women, discrimination & stigma against LGBT, presence of manual scavenging for lower caste bring out the existence of structured inequalities.

With passage of time society is moving towards newer dimensions of stratification.

More on Class, Status, Gender and Race

Stratification by class, status group, gender, ethnicity and race.

All Sociology I questions on Class, Status, Gender and Race