Sociology I · 20 marks

Critically examine Max Weber's theory of social action and its limitations.

Answered by 4 toppers · CSE 2017–2020

Syllabus: Sociological Thinkers: (a) Karl Marx- Historical materialism, mode of production, alienation, class struggle. (b) Emile Durkheim- Division of labour, social fact, suicide, religion and society. (c) Max Weber- Social action, ideal types, authority, bureaucracy, protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism. (d) Talcolt Parsons- Social system, pattern variables. (e) Robert K. Merton- Latent and manifest functions, conformity and deviance, reference groups. (f) Mead - Self and identity.

How toppers approached it

From 3 of the 4 answers · about 350 words.

Opening

  • A definition3 of 3

Body

  • Points and prose2 of 3
  • Points1 of 3

Close

  • A summary2 of 3
  • No separate close1 of 3

The toppers’ answers

Maithreyi NaiduAIR 27 · CSE 2020 · 354 wordsTheir whole copy

Opening · a definition

Max Weber held that sociology is the study of social action. He defined social action as meaningful behaviour of an individual subjectively oriented towards another actor.

Therefore, according to Weber's theory of social action, behaviour is simply response to stimuli such as shivering in cold weather. Action is when the actor attaches meaning to the behaviour and consciously acts, for example wearing a sweater to protect from the chill. Finally, social action occurs when the actor orients his or her meaningful action towards the other actors such as choosing a sweater because it will appear fashionable to others. It is this social action which is the subject of study within sociology.

Further, Weber holds that the orientation of the action may be of four types:

Body · points and prose

(i) rational orientation where the actor logically selects the goals and then

selects the most efficient means to achieve those goals. (ii) affective orientation where the actor acts on the basis of emotional attachment such as fear, happiness etc (iii) traditional orientation where the actor acts in a particular way because it has been done so in the past (iv) value rational orientation where the actor selects the action based on certain values such as courage, truth, patriotism etc.

Close

When actions are repeatedly performed, they give rise to various forms of social relationships such as norms, fashions, institutions etc.

Weber's emphasis on the central role of social action in sociological analysis has been criticized by structuralists for its ignorance of the role played by social structures in shaping individual actions. Both functionalists such as Parsons and conflict theorists such as Marxist sociologists have argued that the individual does not have absolute freedom in choosing between multiple

courses of action and his actions are invariably guided by role and status occupied by him in the social structure.

To address this criticism, Giddens has proposed the neo Weberian theory of structuration where structure and action both contribute to shape and develop each other.

Other critiques of Weber's theory include the lack of predictability as actions are completely subjective, and inability to explain how society is maintained if individuals are completely creative.

More on Max Weber

Social action, ideal types, authority, bureaucracy, and the Protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism.

All Sociology I questions on Max Weber