GS4 · 10 marks · 150 words

B. "I am a Moslem; I am a Hindu; I am a Christian; I am a Jew." Mahatma Gandhi. What did Mahatma Gandhi mean by the above statement? Some philosophers have argued that religion is harmful to the moral life, whereas others have claimed that it is necessary to it. Explain your position on the relationship between religion and morality.

Answered by 4 toppers · CSE 2022–2024

Syllabus: Ethics and Human Interface: Essence, determinants and consequences of Ethics in-human actions; dimensions of ethics; ethics - in private and public relationships. Human Values - lessons from the lives and teachings of great leaders, reformers and administrators; role of family society and educational institutions in inculcating values.

How toppers approached it

From all 4 answers · about 310 words · 50% drew a diagram.

Opening

  • No separate opening3 of 4
  • A direct answer1 of 4

Body

  • Points and prose3 of 4
  • Points1 of 4

Close

  • A summary2 of 4
  • A way forward2 of 4

The toppers’ answers

Divyank GuptaAIR 21 · CSE 2024 · 391 wordsTheir whole copy

Opening

India under the constitutional values has established itself as a welfare state where public service delivery becomes important.

Public Service Attitude means the attitude required for service delivery (Eg) Integrity, Transparency, Accountability, Objectivity etc. It is formed due to

Body · points and prose

  • Values of the person (Eg) Verghese Kurian
  • Values cherished by the institutions
  • Learnings from the Seniors

Attitude Bias affect a public Servant decision Making

  1. Bias in attitude can force public servant to think that public is wrong and it can make him hostile.
  2. This hostility can lead to apathy (eg) Chhattisgarh DM threw phone of a boy.
  3. Animosity towards people of a religion can lead to hatred.
  4. lack of trust within organisation can impact work culture and deter sound actions.

Public servant can overcome this bias by

  • showing empathy and connecting with people (Eg Gandhij's Darshan
  • learning about ground Realities
  • Be open in changing own attitude through New learning
  • Inspiration from role model like TN Seshan

As John F Kennedy said that govt highest responsibility is to develop right attitude among public servant. There through Mission Karmayogi it must be done.

Mahatma Gandhi through the above quote tries to say that there is oneness in Religion. All Religion are ways to achieve the higher self of ours. Therefore, there is difference only in name and not in faith.

Religion is harmful to Moral life

  1. Religion causes hatred among people Eg: Communalism 2002 Godhara Riots
  2. Religion causes hierarchy among people and treats people as means
  3. Religion Values are often Misinterpreted Eg: Jihad in Islam
  4. Religion is needed for promoting intolerance

However Religion is Necessary to Moral life as

(1) All Religion promote human goodness. (2) Religion enforce and ensure Values of Compassion, empathy etc. (3) Religion guides law and Regulation Eg Idea of Justice under DPSP. (4) Religion promotes Harmony Eg Tolerance and Pluralism in Hinduism. (5) Religion guides people towards bigger purpose Eg Nirbal ke balram - Gandhiji uphold to universal religion Values.

  • Way for Religion and Morality
    • punish people promoting hatred (Eg Amish Devgan Case on Hate speech)
    • promote religious education among students (Eg Wardha School)
    • promote good values like Tolerance

Close · a way forward

Religion should be seen as an mean of human development and not an end to promote Morality.

More on Indian Thinkers

Moral thinkers and philosophers from India used as a source: Gandhi, Buddha, Vivekananda, Kautilya, Tiruvalluvar, Ambedkar, Kabir and others.

All GS4 questions on Indian Thinkers