Ravi is a senior police officer with vast experience in riot control and cyber-policing. Since one year, he has been the Superintendent of Police (SP) of a district with a history of frequent rioting. Last year, Ravi had sought installation of an AI enabled software for predictive policing. This system has been operational for approximately six months. This new system employs advanced algorithms for capturing the biometric data of persons in a crowd and swiftly relating it to a data library. This has enabled the police to identify the persons involved in various crimes. The system has identified an immigrant and low-income neighbourhood as a centre for gang violence and drug trafficking. Aided by this AI analysis, the local police has focused its patrolling, preventive detentions and establishing checkposts. Consequently, public order and law enforcement has visibly improved. Last week, some community leaders, civil rights lawyers and human rights activists visited Ravi’s office. They submitted a memorandum that the new system is faulty as it is based on incorrect historical data caused by social biases and discriminatory policing. The memorandum also alleges that the increased surveillance has created a climate of tension amongst residents. This feeling is aggravated by the fact that the residents are not aware of the data noted against their names.

How a topper answered the closest question

Toppers wrote this one in a test series: “You are posted as the Deputy Commissioner (DC) in a district straddling Haryana and Rajasthan, which has been repeatedly flagged in recent years as a hotspot for cybercrime and online financial fraud. Several nationwide scams involving OTP frauds, fake KYC calls, and online loan apps have been traced to villages in this region. While investigative agencies across states have linked multiple frauds to clusters of young men from the region, the narrative in media and even among law enforcement is becoming increasingly communalized and stigmatizing. Terms like “Cyber Jihad”, “Scam Villages”, and “Digital Jamtara” are being used casually. On the ground, the situation is complex. The region has suffered from long standing neglect: poor schooling, lack of internet literacy, unemployment, low policing infrastructure, and weak digital awareness. Many innocent villagers, particularly from marginalized communities, are being indiscriminately raided or detained based on flimsy digital footprints or IP mismatches. Local youth feel demonized, even when seeking honest employment, and there's growing mistrust between communities and police. On the other hand, rising cybercrime incidents undermine public trust in digital services, hurt national financial security, and burden law enforcement across India. You are under pressure from state and central agencies to deliver swift arrests and “crackdown hard.” Yet, you are also mindful that indiscriminate action may further alienate local communities and deepen socio-religious fault lines. (a) Identify the ethical issues involved in this case. (b) What will be your action as Deputy Commissioner (DC)? (c) What will be your action as District Magistrate (DM)?”

Toppers’ answers to other close questions

• As the Superintendent of Police in your state, you are renowned for your impartiality and dedication to upholding the rule of law. Recently, Raju, a compassionate young man from the local tribal community, attended a fair in the local bazaar. During the event, he witnessed a group of non-tribal students assaulting a mentally ill woman, accusing her of theft. Raju intervened to defend the woman, which led to a heated confrontation with the group. The situation was temporarily defused by local shopkeepers. Later that night, as Raju was returning home, the same group of intoxicated individuals attacked him, causing severe injuries. The following day, Raju was found critically injured in an agricultural field, having been electrocuted. Upon learning of the incident, the tribal community retaliated by attacking properties belonging to the non-tribal group. That night, the violent mob set fire to 37 shops and six houses owned by non-tribals, escalating communal tensions. Non-tribal families, including school, college, and hospital staff, fled to nearby jungles seeking safety due to the perceived lack of immediate police intervention. You have been informed of the situation by your subordinates, and government officials have tasked you with restoring order and enforcing the rule of law in the region. In the given situation answer the following: a) Identify the ethical issues in the case. b) As the Superintendent of Police, what steps will you take to restore the rule of law and address the escalating violence in the region? c) What strategies would you recommend to promote social cohesion and address the communal divisions in the affected area? [20M]1 answer
• You are posted as the Superintendent of Police (SP) in a district of Manipur that has been severely affected by ongoing ethnic violence between 2 tribal communities. Over the past several months, dozens of people have been killed, hundreds injured, and thousands displaced. Several incidents of mob lynchings, arson, sexual violence, and looting have taken place. Both communities accuse each other of betrayal and violence. The state police and paramilitary forces are deployed, but trust has broken down. Even civil servants and police officers are being viewed with suspicion, based on their ethnic identity. You are ethnically neutral and not from the state, but your district team is diverse and includes officers from both communities. The situation is tense. The Internet is shut down. There is media pressure, social media outrage and conflicting narratives. One night, a violent mob from one community surrounds a refugee camp where families from the other community are sheltered. They are demanding that some "culprits" be handed over to them, claiming those people were involved in a previous attack. You receive real-time information that if the mob is not dispersed peacefully, it could lead to a massacre, but if force is used, it could trigger a larger retaliation across districts. You have limited police presence and only one central force unit available on standby. Adding to the pressure, The Chief Minister's office has informally told you to "avoid escalation" at all costs. A senior local MLA, from the same community as the mob, is allegedly protecting instigators. A journalist from a national media house has arrived at the camp and is recording live videos, which could go viral. (a) In the context of the case study, discuss the role of declining social capital in disturbing community harmony. (b) What immediate actions would you take to prevent violence without violating law or escalating tensions? (c) Which principles of constitutional morality should guide your action in this situation? How would you ensure their application under intense public, media and political pressure?1 answer
• You are a young officer posted as the Superintendent of Police (SP) in a district. You have received information that at a party some people were harassed by your subordinate police officer. On further inquiry, you came to know that two complaints have been filed - one by the police and the other by people who organised the party. According to the police, people had gathered without permission and were not following COVID-19 appropriate behaviour and social distancing norms. But on the other hand, the complaint filed by the party organisers says that police entered the private venue due to loud noise and harassed everyone at the party including women guests. According to them, your subordinate police officer even tore apart the document, which granted permission to organise the party. A video of this incident, showing your subordinate officer tearing off a document, is being widely circulated on social media platforms. Due to this, social activists want you to take strict action against your subordinate police officer. (a) Identify the ethical issues in the case. (b) What are the factors that can influence decision by competent authorities in such instances? Do you think mobilising public opinion through social media is a fair way to influence the decision in such cases? (c) As the SP, what will be your course of action in this situation?7 answers