ApsaraAIR 192 · CSE 2024 · 259 wordsTheir whole copy
Opening
Indian bureaucracy called as the 'Steel Frame of India' by SV Patel plays a major role in administrative process.
Body · points and prose
Generalist vs Specialist:
| Generalist | Specialist |
|---|---|
| 1. Bureaucrat with general knowledge without any subject specialization | 1. Bureaucrat should have specialized knowledge & domain experts |
| 2. Helps in policy making in higher levels to have a holistic view | 2. Specialist are essential to solve a issue with subject specific view |
| Eg: Consider needs of wider sections SC/ST/ women in policy formulation | Eg: More role in ground level issues like disaster management & emergency crisis |
- Both generalist & specialist views are
important for the diverse Indian society
- Selecting specialist for role of Joint secretary & above as per Hota committee recommendations may holds good.
Lateral entry of specialist:
Lateral entry of specialist is the entry of specialist into bureaucracy at higher level without resorting to normal selection process.
Benefits:
- Subject specialization & expert helps in effective planning & mobilization
- Increased efficiency due to domain/field knowledge.
- Helps to adopt best practices in the field
- Efficient resource utilisation by experts
Concerns:
- Against constitutional process of recruitment
- Lack of adequate training and experience in job
- Opening up to privatisation of bureaucratic services.
- chances of political influence & vested interest.
- Questions the ability of senior bureaucrat without examining.
Close · a way forward
Lateral entry is a positive step but robust & transparent recruitment process should be adopted as recommended by II ARC report.
How toppers approach this question, and more on its topic: open the question.