Ghazalpreet KaurAIR 529 · CSE 2022 · 307 wordsTheir whole copy
Opening · a definition
Alternate Dispute Resolution (ADR) mechanisms are the new judicial tools to decrease burden on Indian courts for the adjudication of the disputes.
Body · points
Potential to change judicial landscapes:
Decrease pendency of cases: As per National Judicial grid, there are approximately 3 crore cases pending in various courts in India. ADR can help to take some of these cases.
Timely disposal and faster justice: E.g → Lok Adalats try to resolve cases faster within 2-3 months. This gives timely justice to victims.
Promote Ease of Doing Business: Resolution of cases is one of [the] enforcement of contracts is one of the reasons for low EDB rank in India, even the [performance] lower than expected. India's New Delhi International Arbitration Centre bill has not yet passed.
Increases confidence of people on Judiciary: with timely resolution of cases, status of judiciary increases.
Allow higher judiciary to focus on Constitutional Problems.
Affordable justice: No fee charged by Lok Adalats. Poor can access justice because litigation in higher courts is very costly. But the use of ADR cannot be universalised. It has certain limitations which hinders their use in large scale:
Not suitable for every case: For cases like sexual violence, abuses, murder etc, [only] courts [can] decide the case.
Decrease and question the Constitutional court's judicial powers: ADR is not constitutional in nature, where courts have constitutional mandate to uphold justice.
Right to privacy: Protection of interest of privacy of accused and victim is the foremost concern.
People's acceptability is low:
Close · a way forward
Even after cases are resolved, still appeals done in the courts leading to increase in pendency.
Thus ADR mechanisms are need of an hour but must be used only for specific cases especially commercial cases and consumer cases. For rest, judiciary's infrastructure and vacancies must be addressed to resolve cases timely.
How toppers approach this question, and more on its topic: open the question.