AIR 22 · GS2 · 53 pages

Anshul: GS2 answer copy

1 answer by Anshul, as written in the test. Each question opens a page with how other toppers answered it.

The questions

The answers

Question · 157 words written

Interstate disputes are increasingly becoming intractable problems and causing significant bad blood between states. Discuss the constitutional and legal framework to resolve these disputes and explain why these mechanisms have failed to achieve the desired results. Suggest a joint approach for their resolution.

Opening

Interstate disputes are increasingly becoming intractable problems and causing significant bad blood between states eg. Killings on Assam border disputes

Body

Constitutional and legal framework to resolve disputes

  • Interstate Council under Article 263.
  • Interstate water disputes (Article 262) → River water boards Act → interstate water disputes Act
  • Zonal Councils Act; standing committee of interstate council
  • North East councils Act
  • Meetings between CMs, chief secretary's etc
  • Article 131 - Original Jurisdiction SC

These promote interstate solidarity and communication and help resolve interstate disputes.

Why independent India failed to solve disputes

  • Non-functioning of interstate councils and zonal council → They have remained non-functional, have met only once or twice in 4 year.

  • Political interests - for getting votes

  • Regional and linguistic chauvinism

  • Attitude of no-compromise between states

Diagram
* Unsolved disputes * Kasargod * Belgaum * Assam Border * between Haryana & Punjab * Hyderabad issue

Close

Although many committees have been formed some disputes remain unsolved. A joint approach which is proactive rather than reactive must be followed.