Sociology I · 10 marks · 150 words

Though Positivism became a powerful sociological method, it had its critics. Elucidate.

Answered by 4 toppers · CSE 2024–2025

Syllabus: Sociology as Science: (a) Science, scientific method and critique. (b) Major theoretical strands of research methodology. (c) Positivism and its critique. (d) Fact value and objectivity. (e) Non-positivist methodologies.

How toppers approached it

From all 4 answers · about 200 words · 50% drew a diagram.

Opening

  • A definition4 of 4

Body

  • Points3 of 4
  • Points and prose1 of 4

Close

  • A summary4 of 4

The toppers’ answers

Malavika G NairAIR 45 · CSE 2024 · 177 wordsTheir whole copy

Opening · a definition

Positivism was introduced by St. Simon and Comte as a method to understand society. As a Powerful sociological method:

Body · points and prose

Positivism

  • Confirm what is, than what should be
  • Use scientific method
  • observation, Comparison and classification
  • Theory building and science of society
  • e.g.: 'Social physics'/'social dynamics'- by Comte.

As a Powerful sociological method:

  1. Positivism provided an objective approach to study social reality e.g.: Religion as 'sacred things' by Durkheim rather than 'fear of God/supanatural' i.e common sense views.
  2. Use of scientific method and theory building e.g.: Durkheim's social facts, Totemism as Religion.
  3. Use of empirical evidences as base e.g.: marx used Blue Books to develop historical materialism.
  4. Brought sociology at par with natural sciences

Ej) Weber's Ideal type concept as a way of social science experimentation.

CRITICS OF POSITIVISM

  1. Ignore subjective meanings assigned by humans - [Schutz]
  2. Action are not cultural dopes without any free will - Phenomenologists like [Garfinkel]
  3. Low reliability and validity of social research due to bias of researcher.
  4. Incomplete and mimicking of the physical sciences.
  5. 'Grand Theories' are not conducive to present development of sociology - [Merton]

Close · a summary

Merton's Middle Range theories and [Peter Berger]'s 'sociological imagination' is an ideal balance that reconciles both advantages and critiques of positivism.

More on Positivism and Its Critique

Comte's and Durkheim's positivism and the critiques of it.

All Sociology I questions on Positivism and Its Critique