Rahul JainAIR 21 · CSE 2018 · 406 wordsTheir whole copy
Opening
The above case highlights the issue faced by private firm of shifting its operations due to declining profit, increasing regulations & increasing politicisation in the trade union. Job losses due to migration is a case of concern.
Stakeholders → (1) Chief executive
Body · points and prose
(2) Worker who will loss jobs (3) Society at large due to environmental issues (4) Shareholders
(a) Ethical issues involved
- Shifting of location so as to evade law of land (environmental laws).
- Profit motive of company & its social responsibility towards its employees.
- Behaviour of workers & unions to increase wages in such adverse times being a part of company
- Sudden change of environmental law by government... is it just? Should it be fiat or gradual?
- lapse of governance in implementation of environmental laws?
(b) As a CEO of company my primary responsibility is to adress the interest of all stakeholders i.e. Shareholders, trade unions workers etc. without affecting profits of company & simultanously adhering to law of land. Thus my intervention should be in this regard.
Trade Unions/Workers
- Will identify the issues & demands of workers
- Will setup a meeting with union leaders & will highlight them the present issues of company's profitability
- Will highlight the picture of unfortunate events which may appear if company has to shut its operations
- Will persuade/convince them to take back their demands & get back to work & will assure them of good returns once the company gets back to profitability (if demands are just & fair)
Shareholders
- Will identify their concerns
- Will persuade them not to shift as shifting to evade laws following other companies is not a appropriate solution as it is a corrupt practice & also some day same norms if appropriate will be applied there as well (new location)
- Will convince them of finding the best possible solution in interest of company.
With respect to environmental norms
- Will check the desirability of such norms
- Will write a letter to Secretary & Minister highlighting the issue in adhering to such norms & will highlight the issues (if laws is unjust) or will ask him for adequate time frame (if laws are just) to adhere to norms.
- Will also highlight the evasion practices done by other industries - (Act of Probity) & will persuade him to take swift action
Close · a summary
Thus in this way interest of all stakeholders can be reconciled.