GS3 · 10 marks · 150 words

It has been pointed out that competitive politics to fund mostly non-merit subsidies is pushing a few states in India to the brink of a deep fiscal crisis. In this context, discuss the need to rationalise the subsidy regime in India.

Answered by 5 toppers · CSE 2022–2025

Syllabus: Government Budgeting.

How toppers approached it

From all 5 answers · about 160 words · 80% drew a diagram.

Opening

  • A constitutional or legal provision40%
  • No separate opening40%
  • A figure20%

Body

  • Points60%
  • Points and prose40%

Close

  • A way forward80%
  • No separate close20%

The toppers’ answers

AnanyaAIR 13 · CSE 2025 · 213 wordsTheir whole copy

Opening

The recent concern raised on the freebie culture (non merit subsidies example) by 15th Finance Commission as well as our PM has raised discussions on it.

Non Merit Subsidies includes:

Body · points

  • Free power (in agriculture)
  • Free Bus Ride / Train ride
  • Free electricity
  • Free laptops, etc
  • free usage of other public service
  • Farm Loan waivers, etc.

Non merit subsidy → Deep Fiscal Deficit of few state

  1. States like Punjab have high Debt to GDP ratio (≈ 53% reached)

  2. States like UP, Telangana too suffer from high Fiscal Deficit

  3. States combined debt - GDP ratio ≈ 31% of GDP (against ideal 20% of GDP)

  4. This leads to fiscal unsustainability of many states

Need → Rationalise subsidies

  1. To optimise the fiscal deficit of India (Presently ≈ 6.9% of GDP)
  2. To reduce the debt - GDP ratio of the country ( ≈ 85% of GDP)
  3. To prevent sub national bankruptcy
  4. To sustain the welfare efforts in long run
  5. To prevent over dependency of people on state → counter dependency on doles
  6. To have money for increasing

Close · a way forward

capital expenditure → promote investment

Hence subsidies need to be rationalised. For this the recommendation of FRBM review committee can be taken up

More on Fiscal Policy and Budgeting

The Union and State budgets, fiscal deficit, FRBM, off-budget borrowing, counter-cyclical spending, devolution of revenue.

All GS3 questions on Fiscal Policy and Budgeting