GS2 · 15 marks · 250 words

'The delimitation process creates a wedge between representative democracy and federalism.' Examine. Also suggest measures to address the concerns of federal units.

Answered by 5 toppers · CSE 2023–2025

Syllabus: Functions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure, devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein.

How toppers approached it

From all 5 answers · about 220 words · 40% drew a diagram.

Opening

  • No separate opening60%
  • A definition20%
  • A constitutional or legal provision20%

Body

  • Points80%
  • Points and prose20%

Close

  • A way forward60%
  • A summary40%

The toppers’ answers

Shakti DubeyAIR 1 · CSE 2024 · 279 wordsTheir whole copy

Opening

Women Reservation Act & disparity in population dynamics between Northern and southern states has raised concerns over Delimitation exercise due after census 2026.

Delimitation Process :-

Body · points

(1) It's defined as the process of redrawing the boundaries of the constituencies based on data of recent census (2) 84th Amendment Act, 2002 had freezed the delimitation exercise till 2026 (3) Art-80 of Indian constitution provides for - Parliament to enact a Act for Delimitation (4) The process is carried out by Delimitation commission - which is to be created by President (5) Order of the commission are final & binding and cannot be challenged in any court of law

Issues with Delimitation :-

The process have be entailed to ensure representativeness of the population, however it faces challenges like :- (1) It creates a wedge between representative democracy & Federalism (2) It creates an imbalance/inequality of representation between different states at the centre (3) The criteria for delimitation is - Population - which is a cause of concern for southern states (4) It tilts the Balance of power towards states with higher population as they capture more seats (5) states have no say in the

delimitation commission.

Measures to address the concern of Federal Units :-

(1) The Delimitation commission should consist of members from states eg :- The model of NITI Aayog or GST council can be copied (2) The criteria for delimitation should move beyond population eg :- Finance commission using multiple criteria for financial devolution (3) The states should be allowed to put forward their grievances if any

Close · a way forward

Thus, there is a need to ensure cooperation between centre and state instead of creating a centralised authority for delimitation.

More on Federalism

The federal structure, its asymmetries and the balance the Constitution strikes.

All GS2 questions on Federalism